Following the election of Pope Leo XIV, the first American pope hailing from Chicago, reactions varied from patriotic celebration to admiration for the new leader. While many expressed pride and hope for a unifying figure amid political tensions, others remained unaware of the new pope's background, reflecting a diverse range of sentiments within the Catholic community and beyond.
Historic Moment as Chicago's Cardinal Becomes First American Pope

Historic Moment as Chicago's Cardinal Becomes First American Pope
The election of Pope Leo XIV, the first pope from the United States, ignites a blend of pride and curiosity across the nation.
The election of Cardinal Leo XIV, the first American pope, has caused astonishment and joy among Catholics and non-Catholics across the United States. Born in Chicago, Pope Leo XIV’s ascension has sparked a wave of patriotic sentiment, as Americans prepare to celebrate their nation’s 250th anniversary. Many view his election as a symbol of a new chapter for the Catholic Church within the American context.
“This is something new and fresh for us,” remarked Alex Freeman, a 33-year-old event planner from Atlanta who, although raised Baptist, attends Catholic services at a diverse congregation. “It speaks to a new American narrative.”
In Chicago, the mood was especially jubilant, where locals celebrated the news of having a pope from their city. Rev. William Lego of St. Turibius Parish expressed awe and pride at his old classmate's election, stating, “They picked a good man.”
Reactions on social media were animated; political strategist David Axelrod echoed many with his surprise: “Holy smokes!! An American pope! From Chicago!!”
However, not everyone was familiar with the new pope before his election; some voiced surprise, having never known of a cardinal from the U.S. prior to the announcement. Danielle Charles, a 33-year-old insurance professional in San Antonio, shared her shock, remarking, “I didn’t even know there was a cardinal from the U.S. in the running.”
The sentiments were similarly mixed in Queens, where retired accountant Rosario Gonzales, a Filipino immigrant, said she had no preference regarding the pope's nationality. “It doesn’t matter what nationality the pope is,” she stated. “He’s still my pope.” Her optimism was palpable as she hoped Leo XIV would carry on the compassionate outreach encouraged by Pope Francis.
As the nation absorbs this historic event, the responses mirror the diversity of the American population itself, blending pride, curiosity, and aspirations for a unifying leader within the Catholic Church during challenging times.