Monsignor Jamie Gigantiello’s actions have sparked allegations of financial and managerial misconduct beyond the music video controversy.
**Music Video Controversy Leads to Dismissal of NYC Priest**
**Music Video Controversy Leads to Dismissal of NYC Priest**
A New York priest faces dismissal after allowing a popstar to film provocative scenes in his church.
Monsignor Jamie Gigantiello, a New York priest, has been relieved of his pastoral responsibilities by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn following a controversy surrounding the filming of a music video for popstar Sabrina Carpenter. The Diocese announced this move after an investigation revealed serious instances of mismanagement, prompting a reevaluation of Gigantiello’s role within the church.
The controversy began with Carpenter's October 2023 release of the music video for her song "Feather," which featured provocative scenes filmed inside Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church. Images from the video depicted a crucifix with profanity and Carpenter dancing on the altar, leading to backlash from church officials. The Diocese indicated that proper protocols for filming were not adhered to, expressing their disapproval in a statement.
As part of an internal investigation conducted by Alvarez & Marsal and Sullivan & Cromwell LLP, Bishop Robert Brennan reported detection of other misconduct beyond the video incident. This included the unauthorized transfer of approximately $2 million in church funds to accounts associated with a former aide to New York City Mayor Eric Adams, whose administration has faced scrutiny and indictments for various alleged crimes, including bribery and wire fraud.
Gigantiello’s administrative powers were revoked in November 2022 shortly after the public outcry regarding the music video, with significant findings surfacing during the Diocese’s investigation. In correspondence with parishioners, he acknowledged the decision to allow the filming as a "lapse in judgment." However, he has remained silent about the broader allegations leading to his removal from duties.
The Diocese's statement confirmed that Gigantiello will no longer hold any governance roles, and the church has appointed a replacement to oversee the community. This incident has not only sparked discussions concerning church governance and financial oversight but also reflects a growing concern regarding the intersection of modern culture and traditional practices within religious institutions.
