Noted attorney Gloria Allred, representing Hutchins' family, criticized the dismissal and emphasized their intention to pursue civil action. According to Allred, the criminal proceedings did not adequately address the rights of Hutchins’ family, despite Baldwin's legal protections during the trial process.

The relationship between Hutchins and her family will be a focal point for the civil case, as shown in a statement from her sister, Svetlana Zemko, calling for Baldwin to be held accountable. Baldwin, for his part, has filed documents denying wrongdoing and seeks to put a halt to the civil lawsuit.

Allred did not shy away from critiquing New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez's decision not to appeal the dismissal of Baldwin's charges, expressing frustration with the perceived lack of action in seeking justice for Hutchins' family. Torrez's spokesperson defended the decision, citing procedural irregularities in the criminal case that warranted careful consideration of the family's ongoing grief and broader justice matters within New Mexico.

As this legal saga unfolds, the involvement of Allred—a controversial figure known for her high-profile cases—could influence public perception and the potential outcome of the civil lawsuit against Baldwin and others connected to the production.