China, which has around 10 million Catholics, mandates state approval for bishop appointments, conflicting with the Catholic Church's doctrine that the Pope holds the ultimate authority in ecclesiastical appointments. The ongoing tension results in a divided church environment, where believers must choose between government-sanctioned places of worship or underground churches loyal to the Vatican. The Vatican praised Lin's ministry as compliant with Chinese law and underlined the appointment as a landmark in the dialogue between the two authorities. Chinese foreign ministry officials interpreted this development as proof of the successful implementation of the 2018 agreement and expressed a willingness to foster further engagement with the Vatican. Scholars view the Pope's actions as a potential path toward reconciliation, illustrating a willingness to support diplomatic dialogues instead of escalating tensions.

In prior years, relations between the Holy See and Beijing have been fraught since China severed diplomatic ties in 1951, leading to significant persecution of Catholics during the Mao era. This historical context amplifies the potential implications of the current agreement and recent leadership decisions for millions of believers in the region.