FORT MYERS, Fla. — A federal judge in Florida is pushing for a resolution in a lawsuit concerning detainees at an immigration center located in the Everglades, often referred to as 'Alligator Alcatraz'. The case centers on allegations regarding inadequate access to legal representation for those held at the facility, which was established last summer by the administration of Republican Governor Ron DeSantis.
During a recent status hearing, U.S. District Judge Sheri Polster Chappell directed federal and state legal representatives to meet on December 16-17 in Fort Myers to discuss a potential settlement. Her goal is for all parties to agree on measures that protect detainees' rights without imposing excessive burdens on the facility's operators.
The attorneys representing the detainees have requested a preliminary injunction to streamline the process so their clients can more easily meet and communicate with them. They highlighted logistical issues, such as the necessity for attorneys to schedule visits three days in advance, a requirement not typically found in other detention facilities. Such restrictions often result in attorneys being unable to meet with their clients before critical legal deadlines due to detainee transfers or scheduling delays.
In response, Nicholas J.P. Meros, an attorney for the state, argued that many of the original concerns raised by detainees and their legal teams have since been resolved. He noted that the facility's location in a remote area presents unique challenges in ensuring adequate infrastructure for the number of detainees housed there.
This lawsuit is one of three ongoing federal cases related to the facility. An environmental lawsuit has allowed the center to continue operating for the time being, despite previous rulings suggesting a halt in operations. Additionally, a third case argues that immigration enforcement is a federal responsibility, questioning the state agencies' authority to operate the facility.
Notably, President Trump has previously endorsed the center, suggesting it could serve as a model for future immigration detention facilities nationwide as the push to expand deportation infrastructure continues. Despite criticisms, federal approval has been granted for Florida to receive $608 million in reimbursement for the construction and operation of the facility.
