In brief
In a recent referendum on constitutional reforms, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's support for the 'Yes' campaign was rejected by approximately 54% of voters. This defeat is viewed as a pivotal moment for Meloni, revealing potential vulnerabilities in her government and prompting calls for changes in response to voter sentiments ahead of upcoming elections. The reform aimed to enhance judicial independence but was rejected amid concerns over the balance of power and understanding of the proposal. Meloni has vowed to respect the outcome while acknowledging it as a lost opportunity for modernization.
Italy's Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has lost a key referendum on a constitutional reform which had turned into a vote on her government. The result gives around 54% to the No campaign and 46% to the Yes vote which Meloni had backed.
In a video posted on social media even before all the ballots were counted, Meloni said Italians had voted with clarity and she would respect their decision, but she regretted a lost chance to modernise the country. This defeat marks the first significant setback for Meloni and her right-wing coalition, which has overseen a rare period of political stability for Italy. Opposition parties hailed the result as a sign that voters are looking for change, particularly with a general election due next year.
When the two-day referendum ended on Monday afternoon, exit polls showed the No vote initially leading by a small margin, which grew to a substantial lead as the count progressed. Despite the complex question on the ballot paper, turnout was almost 60%. A high figure had been expected to favour the government, but it was not enough to swing the vote.
The reform voters rejected would have established a firm separation between judges and prosecutors in the constitution and create distinct governing bodies alongside a new disciplinary court. The government argued that the change was critical to enhancing judicial independence, while the opposition countered that it would disrupt a careful balance of powers established post-fascism and increase political influence over the courts.
The intricate nature of the proposal hampered understanding among many Italians, potentially reflecting a communication failure by Team Meloni, and the vote quickly turned into a plebiscite on her nearly four years in office.
Adding to the complexities of Meloni's position are broader political and economic challenges. As a close ally of former US President Donald Trump, Meloni faces rising unpopularity associated with Trump's influence amid concerns over energy costs from the ongoing war in the Middle East.
While Meloni ruled out resigning regardless of the referendum outcome, differing from Matteo Renzi's approach in 2016, the defeat has raised questions about her government's direction. Renzi advised Meloni on the need to heed voter concerns closely.
In defeating the referendum, Meloni's opposition, led by the Democratic Party's Elly Schlein, argues that this result shows the potential for an alternative to her government. With Meloni’s loss diminishing the sheen of her coalition, her political vulnerability has been further laid bare.
