Federal Emergency Management Agency Reforms Face Criticism After Draft Cutdown

Thu Nov 20 2025 04:54:17 GMT+0200 (Eastern European Standard Time)

A draft report on proposed reforms to FEMA has been significantly reduced by the Trump administration, raising concerns about disaster preparedness recommendations being overlooked.

The initial draft of a major report on reforms to the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), originally over 160 pages, has been dramatically shortened to about 20 pages. This move, reflecting the Trump administration's push to lessen federal involvement in disaster management, has alarmed former officials. Many worry that critical recommendations for improving the nation's disaster preparedness may not make it into the final draft, due around December 12. The report's revisions are seen as politically motivated and may ultimately undermine states' abilities to effectively respond to natural disasters.

A draft of a much-anticipated report on reforms to the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has been dramatically reduced in size, with recommendations compiled by a presidentially appointed council cut and altered by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), according to multiple sources.

The report has reportedly shrunk from over 160 pages to approximately 20, prompting concerns among emergency management leaders that crucial recommendations regarding national disaster preparedness may be excluded from the final document, expected around December 12.

This reduction reflects the Trump administration's broader initiative to minimize the federal government's role in disaster management, transferring more responsibilities onto states, tribes, and local territories. Critics argue that this shift places an unreasonable burden on state and local governments, particularly against a backdrop of increasingly severe climate-related disasters.

A former FEMA official observed, The report got nuked, highlighting fears that some recommendations omitted from the draft are vital for effective disaster preparedness and response.

Opponents of diminishing FEMA’s role argue that states lack the capacity to absorb the financial and logistical challenges of rebuilding after disasters. FEMA plays a crucial role in coordinating assistance across various governmental levels, which they believe is essential as the severity and frequency of climate change-induced disasters escalate.

In response to inquiries regarding the updated report, White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson stated that the review council would advise President Trump on how FEMA might be reformed, ensuring that the federal role remains limited and appropriate for disaster scales. Secretary Kristi Noem is reportedly working to align the agency's efforts with the President's vision to better serve the public.

The council, predominantly consisting of members from Republican-led states supportive of significant FEMA reforms, had initially proposed key changes, including faster direct funding for disaster recovery to improve efficiency. However, recent changes to the draft have reportedly stripped sections on mitigation programs and decreased funding for local emergency management agencies.

The future recommendations are expected to require legislative action, primarily aimed at amending the Stafford Act, which governs most of FEMA's functions. As discussions continue amid varying perspectives on how to manage disaster response, the forthcoming report stands as a pivotal moment for future disaster management policy.