Controversial Reopening of Camp Mystic Following Tragic Floods

Tue Dec 23 2025 16:35:45 GMT+0200 (Eastern European Standard Time)

The decision to reopen Camp Mystic after a devastating flood last July has sparked a divisive response among families and local legislators, as the camp prepares to enhance safety protocols for returning campers.

Camp Mystic, a historic girls' Christian camp in Texas, plans to reopen in May after July's catastrophic floods that resulted in the deaths of 27 individuals, including campers. While some families view the reopening as a crucial step in healing, others express outrage at the insensitivity of the decision. The camp's owners are committed to implementing additional safety measures ahead of the new season. Investigative hearings by Texas legislators are forthcoming, yet no blame has been assigned to local authorities. Parents are split on whether to allow their daughters to return, reflecting a broader debate on grief, healing, and safety in the aftermath of tragedy.

Patrick Hotze’s three daughters made it home safe from Camp Mystic after July’s catastrophic floods that killed 25 campers and two teenage counselors. He attended some of the funerals and shares the frustration over the Texas camp's plan to partially reopen next year while intending to send his girls back.

“My heart is broken for them,” Hotze said about parents who lost their daughters, some of whom he described as close friends. “I think it’s different for each kid and each family.”

The 100-year-old all-girls Christian sleepaway retreat will begin enrolling campers in January, aiming to reopen in May on elevated grounds after quickly rising waters swept away two cabins.

For some families, allowing their daughters to return is an essential step toward healing. The flood waters worsened alarmingly during the July Fourth weekend, claiming at least 117 lives in Kerr County alone, with two victims still missing.

Safety Measures and Legislative Scrutiny

In the wake of the floods, Texas legislators are set to hold hearings to investigate the tragedy, though they seem hesitant to assign blame. Local leaders, who were sleeping when the waters rose, continue to defend their actions and are working towards improving a flood warning system before the camp season begins.

Camp Mystic's owners acknowledged the complex emotions surrounding the reopening, stating, “For many of your daughters, this return is not simple, but it is a courageous step in their healing journey.”

While the camp expresses optimism about enrollment, promising enhanced safety measures, including two-way radios and river monitoring systems, outrage persists among some families, particularly those of the victims, who feel reopening disregards the tragedy and the responsibility of camp operators.

Lawsuits from families allege negligence on the part of camp operators who reportedly directed campers to remain in cabins that were in danger of flooding. As distressing accounts of survivors emerge, many parents struggle with the decision of whether to send their daughters back to the camp that holds significant meaning in their lives.

Liberty Lindley’s daughter was among those caught in the flooding but expressed eagerness to return when asked about next year's camp activities. Despite the tragic events, some parents view Camp Mystic as vital to their daughters’ spiritual growth and development.

Conversely, others like John Ball, whose daughter was present during the flood, feel uncertain about returning due to concerns over communication and safety protocols, hinting they may take a sabbatical year to assess the camp’s measures before making a decision.