Zohran Mamdani Retains Police Commissioner Tisch Amid Divided Reactions

Wed Nov 19 2025 22:54:29 GMT+0200 (Eastern European Standard Time)

New York City's Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani secures current police commissioner Jessica Tisch's continuation in her role, a move that highlights ideological differences and varying priorities among city leaders.

Zohran Mamdani, the incoming mayor of New York City, announced that Jessica Tisch would continue as police commissioner, a decision that has elicited mixed reactions from both business leaders and progressive supporters. While Mamdani, a democratic socialist, seeks to reform the police department, Tisch's moderate stance has raised concerns among some of Mamdani's backers who anticipated more radical changes. The appointment reflects a complicated dynamic as Mamdani aims to balance progressive ideals with practical governance.

NEW YORK (AP) — New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani announced Wednesday that the city’s current police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, has agreed to remain in the post, which many view as a significant tactical advantage for the incoming mayor as he seeks to quell concerns over his earlier critiques of the NYPD.

For Mamdani, who has positioned himself as a democratic socialist advocating for police reform and even called for defunding the New York Police Department, this decision marks a pivotal moment in his nascent administration and hints at his future direction in City Hall.

“I have admired her work cracking down on corruption in the upper echelons of the police department, driving down crime, and standing up for New Yorkers,” Mamdani stated. Tisch’s agreement to stay could alleviate worries from influential city business figures and residents who feared that Mamdani's past criticisms might lead to drastic changes in the department structure during a crucial time.

Shared Priorities and Claimed Differences

Despite their divergent backgrounds and some ideological clashes—Mamdani’s progressive vision versus Tisch’s more traditional, establishment approach—the two officials have identified common ground. Mamdani has pledged to shift various responsibilities within the police department towards mental health services, while Tisch, an established authority who hails from a wealthy background, has previously criticized the state’s bail reform laws that Mamdani supports.

After acknowledging their differing views, Tisch expressed confidence in her leadership role under Mamdani’s administration, emphasizing shared goals around stabilizing public safety and reducing crime. Hours following the announcement, they appeared together at a Manhattan memorial for fallen officers, avoiding discussion of their past differences.

Tisch’s Tenure and its Mixed Reception

Appointed to lead the NYPD last November amid scandal and public scrutiny, Tisch’s term has intersected with a decline in several types of crime, drawing favorable responses from business leaders. However, her appointment prompted mixed reactions from Mamdani's progressive support base. Some groups, like the Justice Committee, criticized it as a contradiction of Mamdani's commitments to reform. In contrast, moderate voices such as New York Governor Kathy Hochul praised the choice, suggesting it could prevent federal intervention related to Mayor Mamdani's leadership.

As Mamdani prepares to step into his role, he seeks to surround himself with experienced officials to ensure a seamless transition into governance while addressing concerns about his previously limited public service background.

Overall, this appointment underscores the tension between contrasting visions for law enforcement in New York City, marking a consequential step as Mamdani navigates a complex political landscape.