Growing Discontent: Americans Question Trump's Immigration Tactics Amid Polling Decline

Thu Feb 12 2026 18:52:09 GMT+0200 (Eastern European Standard Time)

Recent polling shows that a significant majority of Americans disapprove of President Trump's aggressive immigration enforcement tactics, with increasing concerns from political independents. The survey reveals a rapid decline in trust for Republican handling of immigration as federal tactics provoke public outcry.

An AP-NORC poll indicates that approximately 60% of U.S. adults think President Trump has overreached with federal immigration enforcement in cities, with many citizens expressing discomfort over military-style tactics. A notable segment of Republicans still support Trump, but disapproval is rising among independents and Democrats, revealing a growing partisan divide on the issue. As both parties' advantage narrows, Trump’s overall approval remains low, igniting discussions about the implications for upcoming midterm elections.

WASHINGTON (AP) — About 6 in 10 U.S. adults believe President Donald Trump has gone too far in deploying federal immigration agents into American cities, according to a recent AP-NORC poll that reveals growing unease among political independents regarding his strategies.

Trump’s approval on immigration, which has declined over the past year, remained steady at approximately 40%. However, the Republican Party's once-clear lead on immigration issues is diminishing, as only around 30% of U.S. adults now trust them more than Democrats, with an equal 30% expressing trust in both parties or neither.

While Trump’s core Republican supporters continue to show strong backing for his immigration policies, there is a noticeable shift among independents. Brenda Shaw, a 65-year-old independent from Michigan, criticized the approach as reminiscent of gestapo tactics, pointing to violent actions by federal agents as a growing concern for citizens. This sentiment is echoed by multiple individuals interviewed who voiced opposition to aggressive enforcement measures.

As federal agents were seen clashing with protesters in cities like Minneapolis, and some U.S. citizens were reported killed amid these operations, roughly 60% of Americans now echo the view that Trump has acted excessively using federal law enforcement for public protests.

Among Republicans, opinions diverge, with only about a quarter believing Trump has overstepped, while half say his actions are about right, and some think he hasn't gone far enough. Younger participants, like Teviss Crawford, express dissatisfaction with the pace of deportations, emphasizing a need for tougher measures against illegal immigration.

Independents have shown increasing disapproval, with approval ratings for Trump's immigration tactics plummeting from 37% to 23% in recent months. Now, 60% in this demographic feel he has gone too far, a significant rise from prior surveys. Maintaining this divide is crucial, as independents traditionally play a pivotal role in elections.

The poll also reveals a significant distrust of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) among the general population, with only about 30% viewing the agency favorably across demographic lines.

Critics argue that Trump's methods divert from constitutional values, with voices like veteran Rick Kinnett expressing disappointment in how military force is used against civilians. Overall, Trump’s immigration policies seem to be increasingly isolating him from moderates and independents, as dissatisfaction grows amidst broader societal concerns.

Despite Trump’s unwavering base, the narrowing gap in public trust between the parties signals a warning for Republicans ahead of the midterm elections. Many independents, previously leaning Republican, now seem to question the party’s direction.

The AP-NORC polling, conducted from February 5-8 with a representative sample of 1,156 adults, underscores a volatile landscape as both parties navigate immigration as a pivotal and contentious issue.